The ACM Journal of Experimental Algorithmics: Review Form

To the reviewer:  Thank you for agreeing to review this manuscript. Visit 
jea.acm.org/guidelines_eval.html for JEA reviewing guidelines.

------------------------
JEA Paper Number:
Title: 
Author(s): 
Reviewer's Name:
Reviewer's Institution: 
Reviewer's Email Address:
------------------------

SOFTWARE AND DATA EVALUATION
You are not expected to certify the correctness of submitted software 
or the validity of submitted data files. Please check that 

[] The software installs and runs. 
[] The instructions for use are reasonably easy to follow. 
[] The code generally appears to produce results compatible with 
   those described in the paper. 

COMMENTS
You are invited, but not required, to comment on the quality of the files 
that accompany the submitted manuscript. 

----------------------------
MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION
Please mark your recommendation: 

 [ ] ACCEPT: The article is suitable for publication in its present form.
 [ ] ACCEPT WITH MINOR REVISIONS: Any required changes are minor; the
     editor will verify that the author made the recommended changes.
 [ ] REVISE AND RESUBMIT: The article is acceptable for publication  
     provided that significant changes are made, as indicated by the 
     comments below.  The revision should be re-reviewed.  
 [ ] REJECT: This article is not suitable for publication in JEA.  

Please mark each category below using the numbers defined here. 
  1: Exceptional, unusually high quality 
  2: Significant, and suitable for publication 
  3: Minor/Questionable, not quite good enough for publication but 
       can likely be improved.
  4: Unacceptable, cannot be made suitable for publication
  X: Unable to decide. 

 [ ] Relevance of this paper to the aims and scope of JEA. 
 [ ] Originality of the results. 
 [ ] Significance/application of the results.
 [ ] Thoroughness of experimentation. 
 [ ] Research methology. 
 [ ] Quality of exposition.  

---------------------------
COMMENTS FOR THE EDITORS 
These comments will be held confidental by the editors. 

------------------------
COMMENTS FOR THE AUTHORS 
These comments will be forwarded to the authors.